Skip to main content

Serving New York

New York Insurance Law 5104: The No Fault Lawsuit Threshold

Hurt in a crash? The insurance company already has a team working on your claim. You should too. A free call tells you where you stand.

  • No Fee Unless We Win
  • Se Habla Español
  • Available 24/7
Paul Perkins, Esq.Your attorneyPaul Perkins, Esq.Of Counsel. Licensed in New York.

Attorney advertising. Services are not available in all states.

See if you have a case

Step 1 of 3

Three steps. Under a minute.

When did the accident happen?

Prefer to talk? Call (646) 212-1017

Free consultationNo cost to ask. No obligation.
No fee unless we winFee terms explained in writing.
Available 24/7Calls answered day and night.
Se habla españolEvery step in English or Spanish.
Licensed attorneysA licensed attorney on every file.
Paul Perkins, Esq.

Reviewed by Paul Perkins, Attorney at Law, Of Counsel. Meet the team

In New York, Insurance Law 5104 limits who can sue an insured driver or owner for pain and suffering. Without a serious injury, the claim is blocked. That is why your medical file matters more than the police report. Build that proof from the start. Call (646) 212-1017 for a free case review.

What does Insurance Law 5104 say?

Between covered persons in a New York crash case, non economic loss needs a serious injury, and basic economic loss cannot be sued for.

New York Insurance Law section 5104 subsection (a) says that in any action between covered persons arising from the negligent use of a motor vehicle in New York, there is no right to recover for non economic loss unless the injured person has suffered a serious injury, and no right to recover for basic economic loss. Two rules live in that one sentence.

First, pain and suffering, the damages that can be a large share of a serious car accident recovery, are off the table unless your injury fits one of the categories defined in New York Insurance Law section 5102 subsection (d). For lawsuits filed since the May 2026 change, eight categories remain, because Chapter 58 of the Laws of 2026 (Part EE) removed the 90 day daily activities category. Second, the first 50,000 dollars of medical bills and lost wages are handled by no fault insurance and cannot be sued for a second time.

The section applies between covered persons, which in practice means almost everyone in a crash involving insured New York vehicles: drivers, passengers, pedestrians and cyclists struck by a car. A motorcyclist is not a covered person under the no fault law, which is why a rider can sue without meeting the threshold.

How do you clear the 5104 threshold?

You clear it with medical proof, such as a doctor's sworn report naming the category and objective findings, not with the facts of the crash.

You clear it with medical proof, not with the facts of the crash. The insurer for the at fault driver will move to dismiss your lawsuit by arguing that your injury is not serious. Your side answers with a doctor's sworn report that identifies the category, states the objective findings behind it, and explains why the injury was caused by this crash rather than by age or a prior condition. The categories that come up in litigation include permanent consequential limitation and significant limitation.

What evidence can decide a threshold motion?

  • Imaging that shows a structural injury, such as a fracture, herniation or tear, taken soon after the crash.
  • Range of motion measurements in degrees, compared to normal, recorded at the first visit and again months later.
  • A treatment history without long unexplained gaps, or a written explanation for any gap.
  • A doctor's opinion that the limitation is permanent or significant and was caused by the collision.
  • Records showing which daily activities you could not do and a doctor's instruction to limit them, which support the limitation opinion.

A worked example

A passenger in a Queens rideshare crash suffers a torn rotator cuff and has surgery four months later. The surgery report, the pre operative MRI and a post operative range of motion test showing a measured loss of overhead reach together establish a permanent consequential limitation. The insurer's motion to dismiss fails, and the case proceeds to a settlement that includes pain and suffering. The same injury, treated with two urgent care visits and nothing more, would likely be dismissed at the threshold stage.

What happens if the court finds no serious injury?

Only the pain and suffering claim ends. No fault benefits stay, and so does a claim against the driver for economic loss above the 50,000 dollar no fault limit, though the case is worth far less. Since judges decide these motions on the papers, early medical records carry the most weight.

Find out what a case like this could be worth

Top USA Law. Services are not available in all states.

Fill in four quick fields, and a licensed attorney reviews the facts of your case at no cost.

Submitting this form does not create an attorney-client relationship. All information is kept confidential.

Where does Top USA Law help in New York?

How Top USA Law handles the threshold in New York

The threshold is the first battle in every case, so the category to prove should be chosen within days and treatment documented objectively.

Section 5104 is the first battle in every New York car accident case. Within days, the category to prove should be identified, treatment should be with doctors who document objectively, and the sworn medical narrative should be ready before the insurer asks for it. Paul Perkins, Of Counsel, is licensed in New York and litigates threshold motions. Start with the New York car accident lawyer page or call (646) 212-1017.

Read on for the serious injury definition, the no fault payment rule and the time limit for suing a private driver who caused your crash.

What deadlines apply to a New York crash?

Sue a private driver within three years. For a city, town or county, give notice in 90 days and sue within one year and 90 days.

Who will handle my case?

A licensed New York attorney, Paul Perkins, Of Counsel, reviews every New York claim, and our team helps you in English or Spanish.

Meet the team
Andranik "Andy" Boyadzhyan, Esq., Founding Attorney, Top USA Law

Andranik "Andy" Boyadzhyan, Esq.

Founding Attorney

Licensed in Alabama, Missouri, New Mexico and Washington, D.C.

Featured in CNN, Forbes, Variety

Paul Perkins, Esq., Of Counsel, Top USA Law

Paul Perkins, Esq.

Of Counsel

Licensed in New Jersey and New York

Certified by the New Jersey Supreme Court as a Civil Trial Attorney. Lawyer of Distinction in Civil Litigation.

Featured in CNBC, Bloomberg, Forbes, The New York Times

He is a distinguished trial attorney recognized for his mastery in civil litigation. A former opera performer turned litigator, Mr. Perkins brings the same discipline and precision from the stage to the courtroom, and has been recognized as a Lawyer of Distinction in Civil Litigation.

Sundas Shafi, Esq., Attorney at Law, Head of Litigation

Rosette Kalayjian, Attorney at Law

Sandra Alves, Case Manager

How does a claim work with us?

Four steps from your first call to the close of your claim. You focus on healing while we deal with the insurers and keep you updated.

  1. Free consultation

    Call 24/7 or send the short form. An attorney reviews what happened and tells you where you stand. Free, no obligation.

  2. We deal with the insurers

    We deal with the insurance companies, request the police report and medical records, and keep you updated.

  3. We build your case

    Evidence, witnesses, experts and the medical picture of your injuries, prepared as if the case will go to trial.

  4. You get paid

    Medical bills, lost wages, vehicle damage, and pain and suffering. No fee unless we win; costs may apply.

Frequently Asked Questions

Who counts as a covered person under section 5104?

A covered person is generally any owner, operator or occupant of an insured New York motor vehicle, and any pedestrian or cyclist injured by one. The threshold in New York Insurance Law section 5104 applies to lawsuits between covered persons. A motorcycle is not a motor vehicle under the no fault law, so a motorcyclist is outside the threshold.

Can I still get my medical bills paid if my injury is not serious?

Yes. Your no fault benefits under New York Insurance Law section 5103 pay medical bills and 80 percent of lost earnings, up to 2,000 dollars a month, within the 50,000 dollar limit regardless of whether your injury meets the threshold. Section 5104 limits only the lawsuit for pain and suffering and for the first 50,000 dollars of economic loss.

Does the threshold apply if the other driver was drunk?

Yes. The threshold in section 5104 does not have an exception for intoxicated or reckless drivers. The driver's conduct matters for fault and for the value of the case, but against an insured driver you still must prove a serious injury under Insurance Law 5102(d) to recover pain and suffering.

How long do I have to meet the threshold?

There is no separate deadline for the threshold itself. A lawsuit against a private driver must be filed within three years under New York CPLR section 214 (a City claim needs a 90 day notice of claim and suit within one year and 90 days), and the serious injury proof is developed inside the case. The filing date, not the crash date, decides which version of the serious injury definition applies: suits filed on or after May 26, 2026 no longer have the 90/180 day category, and the other categories, such as a fracture or a permanent limitation, still apply.

What evidence clears the serious injury threshold?

Medical proof, not the facts of the crash. A doctor's sworn report should name the category, such as a fracture or a significant limitation of use, state the objective findings and explain why this crash, not age or a prior condition, caused the injury. Imaging taken soon after the crash, range of motion measured in degrees at the first visit and months later, and treatment without long unexplained gaps all support that report.

What happens if the court finds no serious injury?

Only the pain and suffering claim ends. No fault benefits stay, and so does a claim against the driver for economic loss above the 50,000 dollar no fault limit, though the case is worth far less. Since judges decide these motions on the papers, early medical records carry the most weight.

Reviewed by Paul Perkins, Esq.

How do you get a free case evaluation?

Fill in the four short fields in this form, and a licensed attorney reviews your case for free. We respond day or night.

  1. Tell us what happenedWhen, where and what kind of crash.
  2. An attorney reviews itAt no cost and with no obligation.
  3. We call you backTo explain your options.

Talk to an Accident Attorney

Top USA Law. Services are not available in all states.

Takes 30 seconds. No obligation.

Submitting this form does not create an attorney-client relationship. All information is kept confidential.