
Andranik "Andy" Boyadzhyan, Esq.
Founding Attorney
Licensed in Alabama, Missouri, New Mexico and Washington, D.C.
Featured in CNN, Forbes, Variety
Serving New York
Hurt in a crash? The insurance company already has a team working on your claim. You should too. A free call tells you where you stand.
Your attorneyPaul Perkins, Esq.Of Counsel. Licensed in New York.Attorney advertising. Services are not available in all states.

Reviewed by Paul Perkins, Attorney at Law, Of Counsel. Meet the team
In New York, the serious injury threshold decides whether you can sue an insured driver who hit you for pain and suffering (motorcyclists are not bound by it). Suits filed since May 26, 2026 must fit one of eight categories, such as a fracture, permanent loss of use or significant limitation; earlier suits keep the 90/180 day category.
Against an insured driver, or through uninsured coverage or MVAIC, pain and suffering needs a serious injury, such as a fracture; motorcycle riders are exempt.
It is the price New York set for fast medical payments: your bills get paid without proving fault, but you may sue for pain and suffering only if the injury is legally serious.
After a crash in New York, the no fault coverage on the vehicle you were in pays your medical bills and 80 percent of lost earnings, up to 2,000 dollars a month, regardless of who caused it, up to the basic economic loss limit of 50,000 dollars in New York Insurance Law section 5102. In exchange, New York Insurance Law section 5104 bars a lawsuit for pain and suffering between covered persons unless the injured person suffered a serious injury as that phrase is defined in Insurance Law 5102(d).
The threshold applies to drivers, passengers, pedestrians and cyclists hurt by insured New York vehicles. It does not apply to motorcyclists, because a motorcycle is not a covered motor vehicle under the no fault law, and it does not touch a claim for economic losses above the 50,000 dollar no fault limit.
In practice the threshold is not decided by an adjuster. It is decided by a judge, on paper, when the defense moves for summary judgment and attaches a report from its own examining doctor. That motion is won or lost on the medical records created in the months right after the crash, which is why what you do in month one matters more than what you argue in year two.
It also explains why two people in the same pain can have very different cases. A driver with a broken wrist clears the threshold on an X ray taken the night of the crash. A driver with a badly hurt neck, no imaging, no measured testing and a two month gap in therapy can lose the same motion while hurting more. The threshold rewards documentation. That is hard to hear, and it is the rule, so the practical answer is to build the record the statute asks for from the beginning.
Injury suits filed since May 26, 2026 lose the 90/180 day category; more fault than the defendants combined bars recovery, except wrongful death.
The category that soft tissue cases could use is gone. For lawsuits filed on or after that date, eight categories remain and being more at fault than the defendant, or the defendants combined, can now bar a motor vehicle injury claim.
| Rule | Before | Lawsuits filed on or after | Statute |
|---|---|---|---|
| 90 out of 180 day category | A ninth category covering a non permanent injury that stopped substantially all usual activities | Removed. Eight categories remain | Insurance Law 5102(d) |
| Shared fault and pain and suffering | Recovery reduced by your share of fault, never barred | Recovery still reduced by your share of fault, and in suits filed on or after May 26, 2026 you recover nothing when you are more at fault than the defendant, or the defendants combined | CPLR 1411 |
| Injured person driving uninsured, or convicted of impaired driving or a felony while driving | No cap | Non economic damages capped at 100,000 dollars if the injured person was partly at fault | Insurance Law 5104 |
| Basic no fault benefits | Up to 50,000 dollars regardless of fault | Unchanged | Insurance Law 5102 |
What this means for a real case is simple. A neck or back injury that hurts, that keeps you off work for four months, but that no imaging or measured testing can pin down, used to have a path through the 90 out of 180 day category. That path is closed for lawsuits filed since the May 2026 change. Every claim now has to land on a category that rests on objective medical evidence: a bone that broke, a scar you can see, a function that is permanently or significantly limited. The practical response is to get the imaging and the measured testing early rather than to rely on a calendar of missed activities.
Top USA Law. Services are not available in all states.
Fill in four quick fields, and a licensed attorney reviews the facts of your case at no cost.
Eight categories. Your injury only has to fit one of them, and the category you plan to prove decides which medical proof your case needs.
| Category | What it covers | Proof used | Possible insurer defense |
|---|---|---|---|
| Death | A crash that kills the injured person | Death certificate, medical examiner and hospital records | Another cause of death |
| Dismemberment | Loss of a body part, severed or amputated | Operative report, photographs | Hard to contest |
| Significant disfigurement | Visible, permanent scarring or deformity | Dated photographs, surgeon on permanence | Scar is small, fading or hidden |
| Fracture | Any broken bone, any size | X ray, CT or MRI with a radiology reading | Old injury, congenital variant, misread film |
| Loss of a fetus | A pregnancy lost because of the crash | Obstetric records before and after | Unrelated cause |
| Permanent loss of use | Total loss of use of an organ, member, function or system | Objective testing plus permanence opinion | Some function remains |
| Permanent consequential limitation | Lasting, more than minor limitation of an organ or member | Imaging plus measured range of motion over time | Degeneration, treatment gap, normal exam |
| Significant limitation of use | More than minor limitation of a body function or system | Imaging plus quantified or qualitative findings | Minor, resolved or subjective only |
Statutory words: an injury that results in death. The category is automatic once the crash is shown to have caused the death. The claim itself changes shape: the estate brings a wrongful death action under New York EPTL section 5-4.1 within two years of the death, and a separate survival claim covers the pain the person felt before dying. What insurers argue: causation, for example that an unrelated medical event and not the crash ended the life. Medical examiner findings and the hospital record answer that.
Statutory words: dismemberment. The loss of a body part, such as a finger, hand, foot or limb, whether it was severed in the crash or amputated by surgeons afterward. Proof is the operative report and the photographs. Nothing about severity has to be argued. What insurers argue: almost nothing on the category itself, so the fight moves to fault and to the value of the loss, including prosthetics, home modification and the work the person can no longer do.
Statutory words: significant disfigurement. New York courts ask whether a reasonable person viewing the injured person would find the condition unattractive, objectionable or the subject of pity. Facial scarring, keloids, skin grafts, burn scars and surgical scars all qualify when they are visible and permanent. Proof is dated photographs over time plus a treating doctor or plastic surgeon on permanence. What insurers argue: that the scar is fading, is small, or sits where clothing hides it.
Statutory words: a fracture. Any broken bone, of any size, anywhere. A fracture needs no degree of permanence and no loss of function. A hairline fracture of a rib, a chip fracture of an ankle and a nasal fracture all satisfy the category on the imaging alone. Proof is the X ray, CT or MRI plus a radiologist reading it. What insurers argue: that the finding is a congenital variant, an old healed injury or a reading error, which is why the imaging should be read by a physician for your side too. Because the category is met by the break alone, fracture cases move fastest: the fight goes straight to fault and value rather than to whether you can sue for pain and suffering at all.
Statutory words: loss of a fetus. A pregnancy lost because of the crash meets the threshold on its own terms, at any stage. Proof is the obstetric record before and after the collision and a physician who connects the loss to the trauma. What insurers argue: that the loss had another cause. Because the medical record is short and specific, this category can be decided on the obstetric chart rather than on an examination months later.
Statutory words: permanent loss of use of a body organ, member, function or system. New York courts read this category strictly: the loss of use must be total, not partial. A paralyzed limb, a blind eye, a removed organ and a joint fused so it no longer moves are examples. A painful, partly limited shoulder is not this category; a claim like that belongs in one of the limitation categories below. Proof is objective testing plus a physician on permanence. What insurers argue: that some residual function remains, which defeats the category.
Statutory words: permanent consequential limitation of use of a body organ or member. This is a category disc, knee and shoulder cases can rely on. It needs three things: a structural injury visible on imaging, a limitation that is consequential rather than minor, and a physician's opinion that the limitation is permanent. The proof that works is a measured loss of range of motion compared against normal values, repeated at intervals, and a final examination close to the motion. What insurers argue: degeneration rather than trauma, a gap in treatment, or a normal examination by their doctor. The difference between this category and the one below it is time: here a physician has to be willing to say the limitation will not resolve, which normally means waiting until treatment has plateaued before that report is written.
Statutory words: significant limitation of use of a body function or system. The same evidence as the category above, without the requirement that the limitation last forever. It must still be significant, meaning more than minor, mild or slight, and it must be shown by objective findings rather than by how much pain you report. A documented radiculopathy with a matching MRI, or a shoulder that measures well short of normal for months, fits here. What insurers argue: that the limitation is minor, that it resolved, or that a subjective complaint is all that is really in the chart. Duration helps. A limitation measured across several months reads as significant. The same finding recorded once, in week two, may not.
With numbers, not adjectives. The two limitation categories carry New York disc cases, and both are decided on objective medical evidence a judge can read.
A record that survives a threshold motion can have four parts. First, imaging that shows something structural: a herniation or bulge that touches a nerve root, a labral or meniscal tear, an annular tear, a rotator cuff tear. Second, range of motion measured with a goniometer or inclinometer and compared to stated normal values, taken more than once, including a recent examination rather than only one from the week of the crash. Third, continuous treatment. Physical therapy that stops in month three and resumes in month fourteen invites the argument that you were fine in between, and if insurance ran out, the record has to say so in writing. Fourth, a physician's narrative that ties the findings to the collision and addresses your prior conditions head on.
That last part decides more cases than anything else. Almost every adult spine shows degenerative change on an MRI, so a report that says only "disc herniation at L5 to S1" hands the defense its argument. A report that says the change was present but asymptomatic, and that the crash converted it into a symptomatic, measurable limitation, is the version that holds. The same logic applies to knees and shoulders. If you had an earlier injury to the same body part, get the old records to your lawyer early instead of hoping nobody finds them.
What does not work: pain diaries alone, a single normal looking examination, a chiropractic note that records tenderness without measurement, or an MRI with no clinician connecting it to your symptoms. New York courts have consistently held that a subjective complaint of pain, standing alone, satisfies neither limitation category.
It helps to know how the motion runs. The defense files first and carries the opening burden, which it can meet with an examination report and a radiologist who reviews your films. If that showing is made, the burden shifts to you, and your answer has to be sworn medical evidence rather than argument from a lawyer. A treating physician's affirmation, with measurements, dates and an opinion on causation and permanence, is the document that defeats the motion. An unsworn letter, a report from a provider who never examined you, or a narrative that ignores your prior records will not do it. If the motion succeeds, the pain and suffering claim is dismissed before a jury ever hears the case, so the affirmation is prepared in advance rather than in the two weeks after the motion lands.
Then the old ninth category still applies: an injury that stopped substantially all usual activities for 90 of the first 180 days.
The change turns on when the lawsuit is filed, not on the crash date. If your lawsuit was already filed before May 2026, the 90 out of 180 day route is still available to you.
That category covered a medically determined injury or impairment of a non permanent nature that prevented you from performing substantially all of your usual and customary daily activities for at least 90 of the first 180 days after the crash. It was the category for people who were genuinely disabled for months and then recovered, and it did not require permanence.
Proving it takes a different record. You need a doctor who actually wrote down the restriction at the time, week by week, rather than a letter composed a year later. You need the 90 days to fall inside the first 180, counted from the crash date. And you need the restriction to reach substantially all of your usual activities, not just work: a person who returned to full duty in week six generally cannot satisfy the category even if the job was miserable. Out of work notes, school records, an employer's attendance file and a household member describing what you could not do at home all carry weight here.
No injury is automatic except the named ones. This table shows which category each listed crash injury can travel under, and what actually decides it.
| Injury | Category to argue | Can it meet? | What decides it |
|---|---|---|---|
| Any fracture, including hairline | Fracture | Yes | Imaging confirming the break and its link to the crash |
| Herniated disc with surgery | Permanent consequential limitation | It can | Operative findings plus post surgical limitation |
| Herniated disc treated without surgery | Significant limitation of use | It can | Measured range of motion loss and continuous treatment |
| Torn meniscus or rotator cuff | Significant or permanent limitation | It can | Whether the tear is traumatic or degenerative |
| Visible facial or limb scarring | Significant disfigurement | It can | Size, location and permanence, shown in photographs |
| Concussion or brain injury | Permanent or significant limitation | It can | Neuropsychological testing and documented deficits |
| Whiplash, sprain or strain that resolves | None available | Not without measurements | Whether any objective limitation was ever measured |
| Loss of a pregnancy | Loss of a fetus | Yes | Obstetric records tying the loss to the crash |
| Paralysis, blindness, organ loss | Permanent loss of use | Yes | Whether any function remains |
With four arguments: a pre-existing condition, a treatment gap, their own examining doctor's report, and complaints of pain with nothing measured.
The same four arguments can appear in any file. Knowing them in month one is how you keep them out of the motion in year two.
Surveillance and social media feed all four arguments. A photograph of you at a wedding, a gym check in or a hiking post gets attached to the motion without the context of what the rest of that week cost you. Assume the defense will find it.
There is also a timing tactic worth naming. Carriers can cut off no fault benefits after an examination concludes that treatment is no longer necessary, knowing a person may stop going when the bills stop being paid. The cutoff and the treatment gap then arrive as a matched pair in the summary judgment motion. Challenging the cutoff quickly, in no fault arbitration, is part of protecting the threshold claim rather than a separate errand.
No-fault benefits, economic losses above the 50,000 dollar limit, property damage and every filing deadline all run whether or not you meet it.
The threshold controls one thing only: pain and suffering from the at fault driver. These parts of your case run whether you meet it or not.
Your no fault benefits are paid regardless of fault and regardless of the threshold, and under New York Insurance Law section 5106 they are overdue if the carrier does not pay within 30 days of proof of claim. Your claim for economic losses above the 50,000 dollar limit, such as surgery bills and long term wage loss, does not require a serious injury. Your property damage claim does not either. And every deadline keeps running while the threshold question is open.
| Deadline | Time | Law or rule |
|---|---|---|
| No fault application | 30 days from the crash | 11 NYCRR 65-1.1 |
| Medical bills to the no fault carrier | 45 days from treatment | No fault regulations |
| Notice of claim against a city or county (a public authority can have a separate statute that sets a shorter deadline) | 90 days from the crash; suit within one year and 90 days | General Municipal Law 50-e and 50-i |
| Personal injury lawsuit | Three years from the crash | CPLR 214 |
| Wrongful death lawsuit | Two years from the death | EPTL 5-4.1 |
File the no fault application on time; a late application can still be accepted with written proof of a clear and reasonable reason for the delay. Our guide to every New York car accident deadline lays those dates out in full.
You do not walk away with nothing. What you lose is the pain and suffering claim, not the rest of the case.
No fault still pays your medical treatment and 80 percent of lost earnings, up to 2,000 dollars a month, within the basic economic loss limit. Economic losses above that limit remain recoverable from the at fault driver, because New York Insurance Law section 5104 restricts non economic loss, not out of pocket loss. Your vehicle damage, rental and diminished value claims are unaffected. A suit against an uninsured driver is not a suit between covered persons, so the threshold does not apply to it. Separately, for injury suits filed since May 26, 2026, Insurance Law 5104(d) caps non economic damages at 100,000 dollars for a partly at fault claimant who was driving uninsured, or was convicted of impaired driving or of a felony committed while driving.
The honest part: a case with no threshold category is worth far less, and a lawyer who promises otherwise is selling something. The better use of the first six months is making sure the category you do have is documented, because a case can fail the threshold on missing measurements rather than on a minor injury. Our page on what a New York car accident settlement is worth explains how that plays out in value.
One more thing worth knowing: the question is not closed forever on the day an adjuster says no. An injury can qualify later. A disc that seemed manageable at month three can need surgery at month ten, and a shoulder that measured close to normal in the spring can be measurably limited by the fall. As long as the lawsuit is filed inside the three year deadline, the record keeps developing and the category is decided on the whole file, not on the first examination. That is another reason not to sign a release early in a case that is still changing.
Clearing the threshold opens the door to a pain and suffering claim; it does not set the amount. How New York values pain and suffering explains what moves that number once the threshold is met.
People also ask about prior conditions, treatment gaps, medical records, pedestrians and riders, the 90 out of 180 day rule and the lawsuit deadline.
No, but it has to be addressed in the medical record. An aggravation of an earlier condition can meet the threshold when a physician reviews the prior records and explains what was asymptomatic before the crash and what is measurable now. Insurers can raise degeneration in any case, so that explanation should be in the chart early, not written for the motion.
A gap is a reason threshold claims can fail, so the reason has to be documented. If treatment stopped because no fault benefits were cut off, because of childcare, work or a pregnancy, or because a doctor released you and symptoms returned, get that in writing at the time. An unexplained gap lets the defense argue you had recovered.
The emergency department record, all imaging with the radiology reports, treating physician notes with range of motion measurements at each visit, physical therapy records, any operative report, and a narrative report connecting the findings to the crash and to any prior condition. Out of work notes and employer records matter for wage loss and for lawsuits filed before May 2026.
It applies to pedestrians and cyclists, but not to motorcyclists. A pedestrian or cyclist struck by an insured New York vehicle is a covered person, receives no fault benefits from that vehicle's insurer, and must meet the threshold to sue for pain and suffering. A motorcycle is not a covered motor vehicle, so a rider gets no no fault benefits and is not bound by the threshold.
For lawsuits filed since the May 2026 change, yes. That ninth category, which covered a non permanent injury preventing substantially all usual activities for 90 of the first 180 days, is no longer available, leaving eight categories in Insurance Law 5102(d). Lawsuits filed before that date can still rely on it, and the proof is contemporaneous records of the restriction.
Three years from the date of the crash under CPLR 214. The threshold proof is developed inside that lawsuit, through the medical record you build beforehand. If a city, county or NYC Transit vehicle was involved, a notice of claim is due within 90 days (other public authorities follow their own statutes), and a wrongful death action is due two years from the death. A lawsuit against a city, county, town or village must then be filed within one year and 90 days under General Municipal Law section 50-i (two years from the death in a wrongful death case).
The category should be picked in the first weeks, then the record that category needs should be built before any defense doctor sees you.
That means ordering the imaging the category depends on, seeing a treating physician who measures and records range of motion at every visit, pulling prior records so the causation opinion addresses them instead of being ambushed by them, keeping the no fault carrier paying so treatment never stops, and preparing the treating physician's affirmation before the defense moves for summary judgment. When the carrier schedules its examination, prepare for it with your lawyer. Paul Perkins, Attorney at Law, Of Counsel, is licensed in New York and litigates threshold motions. Read the Insurance Law 5102 guide, the Insurance Law 5104 guide or the New York car accident lawyer page, and call (646) 212-1017 for a free consultation. No fee unless we win, and costs may apply.
Threshold motions are decided in the county where the case is venued, and the medical proof comes from the hospitals and clinics nearest the crash.
In New York City the motions can be heard in Supreme Court in Kings, Queens, New York, Bronx and Richmond County. The records can come from trauma centers such as Kings County Hospital and Maimonides in Brooklyn, Bellevue and NewYork Presbyterian in Manhattan, Jamaica Hospital and Elmhurst in Queens, Jacobi and Lincoln in the Bronx, and Richmond University Medical Center on Staten Island. Pedestrian cases on Queens Boulevard, Atlantic Avenue and the Grand Concourse can clear the threshold on fractures alone, so those files move differently from a rear end case on the Long Island Expressway. Upstate the same statute applies in Erie, Monroe and Onondaga County, with the imaging coming from the regional systems in Buffalo, Rochester and Syracuse.
Head injuries raise their own threshold questions, because the proof is often in testing rather than on a scan; our New York traumatic brain injury guide explains how they are argued. Crashes with tractor-trailers can produce injuries that clear the threshold, and the Brooklyn truck crash lawyer page covers the carrier side of those cases.
These related New York guides cover the other rules that affect a car accident claim, so you can read the one that fits your situation.
Sue a private driver within three years. For a city, town or county, give notice in 90 days and sue within one year and 90 days.
A licensed New York attorney, Paul Perkins, Of Counsel, reviews every New York claim, and our team helps you in English or Spanish.

Andranik "Andy" Boyadzhyan, Esq.
Founding Attorney
Licensed in Alabama, Missouri, New Mexico and Washington, D.C.
Featured in CNN, Forbes, Variety

Paul Perkins, Esq.
Of Counsel
Licensed in New Jersey and New York
Certified by the New Jersey Supreme Court as a Civil Trial Attorney. Lawyer of Distinction in Civil Litigation.
Featured in CNBC, Bloomberg, Forbes, The New York Times
He is a distinguished trial attorney recognized for his mastery in civil litigation. A former opera performer turned litigator, Mr. Perkins brings the same discipline and precision from the stage to the courtroom, and has been recognized as a Lawyer of Distinction in Civil Litigation.
Sundas Shafi, Esq., Attorney at Law, Head of Litigation
Rosette Kalayjian, Attorney at Law
Sandra Alves, Case Manager
Four steps from your first call to the close of your claim. You focus on healing while we deal with the insurers and keep you updated.
Free consultation
Call 24/7 or send the short form. An attorney reviews what happened and tells you where you stand. Free, no obligation.
We deal with the insurers
We deal with the insurance companies, request the police report and medical records, and keep you updated.
We build your case
Evidence, witnesses, experts and the medical picture of your injuries, prepared as if the case will go to trial.
You get paid
Medical bills, lost wages, vehicle damage, and pain and suffering. No fee unless we win; costs may apply.
Reviewed by Paul Perkins, Esq.
Fill in the four short fields in this form, and a licensed attorney reviews your case for free. We respond day or night.
Top USA Law. Services are not available in all states.
Takes 30 seconds. No obligation.