Skip to main content

Serving New York

CPLR 1411: How Comparative Fault Works in a New York Car Crash Case

Hurt in a crash? The insurance company already has a team working on your claim. You should too. A free call tells you where you stand.

  • No Fee Unless We Win
  • Se Habla Español
  • Available 24/7
Paul Perkins, Esq.Your attorneyPaul Perkins, Esq.Of Counsel. Licensed in New York.

Attorney advertising. Services are not available in all states.

See if you have a case

Step 1 of 3

Three steps. Under a minute.

When did the accident happen?

Prefer to talk? Call (646) 212-1017

Free consultationNo cost to ask. No obligation.
No fee unless we winFee terms explained in writing.
Available 24/7Calls answered day and night.
Se habla españolEvery step in English or Spanish.
Licensed attorneysA licensed attorney on every file.
Paul Perkins, Esq.

Reviewed by Paul Perkins, Attorney at Law, Of Counsel. Meet the team

In New York, CPLR 1411 reduces a crash victim's award by their own share of fault, and for injury lawsuits filed on or after May 26, 2026, it bars recovery for a claimant more at fault than the defendant, or the defendants combined; a wrongful death award is only reduced. Call Top USA Law at (646) 212-1017.

What does CPLR 1411 say?

Subdivision (a) reduces awards by fault; subdivision (b), added in 2026, bars some injury claimants more at fault than the defendant, or the defendants combined.

New York CPLR section 1411 is two paragraphs long. Subdivision (a) says that in any action for personal injury, injury to property or wrongful death, the claimant's own culpable conduct, including contributory negligence or assumption of risk, "shall not bar recovery." The damages are instead "diminished in the proportion which the culpable conduct attributable to the claimant or decedent bears to the culpable conduct which caused the damages." A driver found 30 percent responsible keeps 70 percent of the damages a jury awards.

Subdivision (b) opens with the words "In any action to recover damages for personal injury subject to article fifty-one of the insurance law." Article 51 is New York's no-fault law, so the paragraph is aimed at car crash injury suits. In those suits the claimant's conduct "shall bar recovery" if it is greater than the culpable conduct of the person sued, or greater than the combined culpable conduct of all the people sued.

The Legislature added (b) in Chapter 58 of the Laws of 2026, Part EE, signed on May 26, 2026. Part EE took effect immediately and applies to actions and proceedings commenced on or after that date. The date the lawsuit is filed controls, not the date of the crash, so a 2025 collision sued on in June 2026 falls under the new paragraph.

How does the 2026 bar change a New York crash lawsuit?

From May 26, 2026, more fault than the defendant, or defendants combined, means no recovery; less means a reduced award. Wrongful death is only reduced.

Three examples

  • A driver on the Cross Bronx Expressway changes lanes without signaling and is clipped by a speeding car. A jury puts 25 percent of the fault on the lane changer and 75 percent on the speeder. The lane changer keeps 75 percent of the damages.
  • Two drivers collide while both push a stale yellow on Northern Boulevard, and the jury splits fault 50 and 50. Fifty percent is not greater than the other driver's share, so the injured driver recovers half.
  • A driver who ran a red light on Atlantic Avenue is found 60 percent at fault, and the other driver, who was speeding, 40 percent. In a lawsuit filed on or after May 26, 2026, the red light runner recovers nothing from the speeder.

Does the bar reach only pain and suffering?

No. Subdivision (b) says the claimant's conduct "shall bar recovery," with no exception for lost wages or medical bills. When the bar applies, the whole claim against those defendants ends. The bar does not touch no-fault benefits, which are paid without regard to fault under New York Insurance Law section 5103, so medical bills and part of lost wages are still paid by the no-fault insurer up to the policy limit.

What claims stay under the old pure comparative rule?

Subdivision (b) names only personal injury actions subject to Article 51. Wrongful death is listed separately in subdivision (a) and is not in (b), so a family suing over a death keeps pure comparative fault, with the award reduced by the decedent's share. Property damage claims also stay under (a). Whether (b) reaches a motorcycle rider's own injury suit is not settled: a rider is not a "covered person" under Insurance Law section 5102(j), and the statute does not say whether a rider's suit is "subject to article fifty-one".

How does fault interact with the serious injury rule?

They are separate hurdles. Under Insurance Law section 5104(a), when one covered person sues another, pain and suffering requires a serious injury as defined in section 5102(d). CPLR 1411 then decides how much of the proven claim you keep, or whether you keep any. A second 2026 change, Insurance Law section 5104(d), caps non-economic damages at $100,000, outside death cases, for an at-fault claimant who is not barred and who was driving uninsured (a lapse under 30 days excepted), was convicted of impaired driving, or was committing or fleeing a felony and was convicted of it. Past results do not guarantee a similar outcome.

Find out what a case like this could be worth

Top USA Law. Services are not available in all states.

Fill in four quick fields, and a licensed attorney reviews the facts of your case at no cost.

Submitting this form does not create an attorney-client relationship. All information is kept confidential.

Where does Top USA Law help in New York?

What should you do if the insurer says you were mostly at fault?

Treat the insurer's percentage as an opening position. Preserve video and witnesses, get the police report, and watch the filing date.

Adjusters assign fault percentages to negotiate, and since the 2026 change an insurer can argue that you were more at fault than the defendant, or the defendants combined, to push a claimant toward a low offer. Only a court's ruling, a verdict, or a settlement you accept fixes the split. Collect the police report, photos of both vehicles, dashcam and storefront video, and names of witnesses. In New York City, traffic camera and bus camera footage can be recorded over, so ask for it in writing early. If the other driver was charged with impaired driving under Vehicle and Traffic Law section 1192 or with leaving the scene under section 600, note the docket number.

The filing date matters twice. It decides whether subdivision (b) applies, and the suit must be filed within three years of the crash under CPLR 214(5), or within two years of a death under EPTL section 5-4.1. Worked examples are in our guide to recovering when you were partly at fault in New York, and the threshold is explained in the serious injury categories. A Brooklyn crash case can be filed in Kings County Supreme Court, as the Brooklyn car accident lawyer page explains. Call (646) 212-1017. No Fee Unless We Win (Costs May Apply).

What deadlines apply to a New York crash?

Sue a private driver within three years. For a city, town or county, give notice in 90 days and sue within one year and 90 days.

Who will handle my case?

A licensed New York attorney, Paul Perkins, Of Counsel, reviews every New York claim, and our team helps you in English or Spanish.

Meet the team
Andranik "Andy" Boyadzhyan, Esq., Founding Attorney, Top USA Law

Andranik "Andy" Boyadzhyan, Esq.

Founding Attorney

Licensed in Alabama, Missouri, New Mexico and Washington, D.C.

Featured in CNN, Forbes, Variety

Paul Perkins, Esq., Of Counsel, Top USA Law

Paul Perkins, Esq.

Of Counsel

Licensed in New Jersey and New York

Certified by the New Jersey Supreme Court as a Civil Trial Attorney. Lawyer of Distinction in Civil Litigation.

Featured in CNBC, Bloomberg, Forbes, The New York Times

He is a distinguished trial attorney recognized for his mastery in civil litigation. A former opera performer turned litigator, Mr. Perkins brings the same discipline and precision from the stage to the courtroom, and has been recognized as a Lawyer of Distinction in Civil Litigation.

Sundas Shafi, Esq., Attorney at Law, Head of Litigation

Rosette Kalayjian, Attorney at Law

Sandra Alves, Case Manager

How does a claim work with us?

Four steps from your first call to the close of your claim. You focus on healing while we deal with the insurers and keep you updated.

  1. Free consultation

    Call 24/7 or send the short form. An attorney reviews what happened and tells you where you stand. Free, no obligation.

  2. We deal with the insurers

    We deal with the insurance companies, request the police report and medical records, and keep you updated.

  3. We build your case

    Evidence, witnesses, experts and the medical picture of your injuries, prepared as if the case will go to trial.

  4. You get paid

    Medical bills, lost wages, vehicle damage, and pain and suffering. No fee unless we win; costs may apply.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is New York still a pure comparative fault state?

For most claims, yes, but not for car crash injury suits filed on or after May 26, 2026. CPLR section 1411(a) keeps pure comparative fault for property damage and wrongful death, and for injury cases outside Article 51. Subdivision (b) adds a bar for personal injury actions subject to Article 51 of the Insurance Law: a claimant more at fault than the defendant, or the defendants combined, recovers nothing. At 50 percent or less, the award is reduced by the claimant's share. A rider's motorcycle claim is the one open question.

How is my percentage of fault decided?

A jury decides it at trial, or the judge in a bench trial, after hearing all the evidence. Before then, every percentage is an estimate made by insurers and lawyers to negotiate. The evidence that moves the number is concrete: video, the damage pattern on the cars, event data, the police diagram and independent witnesses. A traffic summons is helpful but not binding in the civil case. Under CPLR section 1411, the finding either reduces the award or, for a covered injury suit filed since May 26, 2026, bars it entirely.

How much will my New York award be reduced if I was partly at fault?

By exactly your percentage, as long as the bar does not apply. CPLR section 1411(a) diminishes damages in proportion to your share of the culpable conduct. If a Queens jury finds damages and puts 20 percent of the fault on you, you receive 80 percent. If your share is greater than the defendant's, or the defendants' combined, in an injury suit filed on or after May 26, 2026, you receive nothing from them. No-fault benefits under Insurance Law section 5103 are not reduced for fault.

Does the crash date or the filing date decide which rule applies?

The filing date. Part EE of Chapter 58 of the Laws of 2026 applies to actions and proceedings commenced on or after May 26, 2026, so a lawsuit filed on that date or later is governed by CPLR section 1411(b) even if the crash happened earlier. A suit filed before May 26, 2026 stays under pure comparative fault. The three year limit in CPLR 214(5) for suing a private driver still runs from the crash (a City claim needs notice within 90 days), so waiting does not avoid the new rule; it only shortens the time left.

Who is covered by the CPLR 1411(b) bar?

People bringing a personal injury action subject to Article 51 of the Insurance Law, which covers the usual car crash suit between drivers, passengers and pedestrians who are covered persons. Families bringing a wrongful death claim are not covered by (b) and keep pure comparative fault under CPLR section 1411(a). A motorcycle rider is not a covered person under Insurance Law section 5102(j), and the statute does not say whether (b) reaches a rider's suit, so a rider should not assume either answer.

What if the insurer says I was mostly to blame for a Manhattan crash?

Do not accept the figure without the evidence. An adjuster's estimate is not a finding, and percentages can move once video, witnesses and the vehicles are examined. Under CPLR section 1411(b), the question is whether your conduct was greater than the defendant's, or the defendants' combined, so identifying every party who contributed, such as a second driver, a contractor or the City, can change the comparison. A claim against the City needs a notice of claim within 90 days under General Municipal Law section 50-e, and the lawsuit must be filed within one year and 90 days under section 50-i.

Reviewed by Paul Perkins, Esq.

How do you get a free case evaluation?

Fill in the four short fields in this form, and a licensed attorney reviews your case for free. We respond day or night.

  1. Tell us what happenedWhen, where and what kind of crash.
  2. An attorney reviews itAt no cost and with no obligation.
  3. We call you backTo explain your options.

Talk to an Accident Attorney

Top USA Law. Services are not available in all states.

Takes 30 seconds. No obligation.

Submitting this form does not create an attorney-client relationship. All information is kept confidential.