Skip to main content

Serving New York

Diminished Value Claims in New York: Asking for the Value a Crash Took From Your Car

Hurt in a crash? The insurance company already has a team working on your claim. You should too. A free call tells you where you stand.

  • No Fee Unless We Win
  • Se Habla Español
  • Available 24/7
Paul Perkins, Esq.Your attorneyPaul Perkins, Esq.Of Counsel. Licensed in New York.

Attorney advertising. Services are not available in all states.

See if you have a case

Step 1 of 3

Three steps. Under a minute.

When did the accident happen?

Prefer to talk? Call (646) 212-1017

Free consultationNo cost to ask. No obligation.
No fee unless we winFee terms explained in writing.
Available 24/7Calls answered day and night.
Se habla españolEvery step in English or Spanish.
Licensed attorneysA licensed attorney on every file.
Paul Perkins, Esq.

Reviewed by Paul Perkins, Attorney at Law, Of Counsel. Meet the team

In New York, a diminished value claim asks the at-fault driver's insurer to pay for the drop in your car's resale value after repair. You must show that driver was at fault and prove the lost value. New York no-fault is injury coverage and never pays for body repair. Call Top USA Law at (646) 212-1017.

What is a diminished value claim in New York?

It is a request for the resale value your car lost in the crash, even after good repairs, made to the driver who caused it.

A car with a crash in its past can sell for less than the same car without one. That gap is called diminished value. In New York, no statute sets a formula for it. The request rides on the ordinary property damage claim against the driver who caused the crash, and the New York Department of Financial Services (DFS) explains on its auto insurance page that to claim on that driver's policy you must establish that the other party was at fault.

Picture a two year old SUV rear-ended at a light on Northern Boulevard in Queens, or a sedan sideswiped on the Long Island Expressway near exit 40. The body shop can make each car look new. A dealer who later sees the crash on the car's history may still offer less. The difference between those two numbers is what this claim is about.

Top USA Law's main office is in Hackensack, New Jersey. Paul Perkins, Of Counsel, is licensed in New York and New Jersey and reviews this page. Our work is injury claims, and when you were hurt in the same crash we can talk with you by phone, by video or in person about how the car claim fits with the injury claim.

How do I make a diminished value claim in New York?

Finish the repair first, then send the at-fault driver's insurer written proof of fault, the repair records and an appraisal of the lost value.

Whose insurance do I claim against?

The other driver's property damage liability coverage. DFS says that policy pays only for the share of the damage the other driver was at fault for. Your own collision coverage is a contract, and it pays what its terms promise. Read the physical damage section of your own policy before you ask your own insurer for lost value.

How does fault split the payment?

For damage to property, New York CPLR section 1411(a) keeps the pure comparative rule: your own share of fault does not bar the claim, but it reduces what you recover by that share. If an adjuster says you were 20 percent at fault for a lane change crash on Queens Boulevard, expect that share to come off the car claim, and push back with photos and the police report if you disagree. If you were also hurt, keep the injury claim separate and sign only a release that covers property damage, so a car check does not end an injury claim.

What proof makes the claim real?

Gather the repair invoice and photos of the damage before and after repair. Add service records that show the car's condition before the crash, and the mileage. A written appraisal from an independent appraiser who compares the car's value before the crash with its value after repair is the core of the claim. The insurer may want its own estimate. Under 11 NYCRR 216.7, when an insurer requires estimates on a collision or comprehensive claim, it bears their reasonable cost.

Can the insurer pick my repair shop?

No. Under New York Insurance Law section 2610, an insurer paying collision or comprehensive coverage may not require repairs at a particular shop, and may not recommend one unless you ask. A shop you trust, with factory parts where they matter, gives you a clean record of what was done.

How much can the claim be worth?

No one can predict a number. The amount turns on the car's age, mileage, prior condition and how serious the frame or structural damage was. The other driver's limits also matter. A New York owner's policy must carry at least $10,000 for damage to the property of others in one accident under New York Vehicle and Traffic Law section 311(4)(a). Past results do not guarantee a similar outcome.

Find out what a case like this could be worth

Top USA Law. Services are not available in all states.

Fill in four quick fields, and a licensed attorney reviews the facts of your case at no cost.

Submitting this form does not create an attorney-client relationship. All information is kept confidential.

Where does Top USA Law help in New York?

What New York deadlines apply to a diminished value claim?

Sue within three years. A city vehicle needs a notice of claim within 90 days and suit within one year and 90 days.

The car claim

New York CPLR section 214(4) gives three years to sue for an injury to property, counted from the crash. Talks with an adjuster do not pause that clock.

A crash with a city or county vehicle

If a city bus, police car or sanitation truck hit you, a notice of claim is due within 90 days under General Municipal Law section 50-e, and suit within one year and 90 days under section 50-i. A public authority bus can fall under a separate statute that can set a shorter deadline.

Your own insurer's timing rules

DFS's guide to claims under your own policy describes Regulation 64. Under 11 NYCRR 216.7, an insurer that chooses to inspect before repair has six business days after notice of the claim to inspect, and must make a good faith offer within that same six-day period. Payment is due within five business days after you accept the offer. DFS adds that you get a written reason if the claim is not settled in 30 days.

Where a lawsuit can be filed

A New York suit can be filed in the county where the crash happened or where a party lived when it was filed, such as Queens County or Nassau County.

Related guides: total loss claims in New York and the New York car accident lawyer page. No Fee Unless We Win (Costs May Apply).

What deadlines apply to a New York crash?

Sue a private driver within three years. For a city, town or county, give notice in 90 days and sue within one year and 90 days.

Who will handle my case?

A licensed New York attorney, Paul Perkins, Of Counsel, reviews every New York claim, and our team helps you in English or Spanish.

Meet the team
Andranik "Andy" Boyadzhyan, Esq., Founding Attorney, Top USA Law

Andranik "Andy" Boyadzhyan, Esq.

Founding Attorney

Licensed in Alabama, Missouri, New Mexico and Washington, D.C.

Featured in CNN, Forbes, Variety

Paul Perkins, Esq., Of Counsel, Top USA Law

Paul Perkins, Esq.

Of Counsel

Licensed in New Jersey and New York

Certified by the New Jersey Supreme Court as a Civil Trial Attorney. Lawyer of Distinction in Civil Litigation.

Featured in CNBC, Bloomberg, Forbes, The New York Times

He is a distinguished trial attorney recognized for his mastery in civil litigation. A former opera performer turned litigator, Mr. Perkins brings the same discipline and precision from the stage to the courtroom, and has been recognized as a Lawyer of Distinction in Civil Litigation.

Sundas Shafi, Esq., Attorney at Law, Head of Litigation

Rosette Kalayjian, Attorney at Law

Sandra Alves, Case Manager

How does a claim work with us?

Four steps from your first call to the close of your claim. You focus on healing while we deal with the insurers and keep you updated.

  1. Free consultation

    Call 24/7 or send the short form. An attorney reviews what happened and tells you where you stand. Free, no obligation.

  2. We deal with the insurers

    We deal with the insurance companies, request the police report and medical records, and keep you updated.

  3. We build your case

    Evidence, witnesses, experts and the medical picture of your injuries, prepared as if the case will go to trial.

  4. You get paid

    Medical bills, lost wages, vehicle damage, and pain and suffering. No fee unless we win; costs may apply.

Frequently Asked Questions

What does diminished value mean for a car in New York?

It means the resale value your car lost because it now has a crash history, measured after the repairs are done. New York has no statute that defines it, so the request is part of the property damage claim against the driver who caused the crash, under the three year deadline in New York CPLR section 214(4). A city vehicle also needs a notice of claim within 90 days.

How do I prove diminished value to a New York insurer?

Send the at-fault driver's insurer a written demand with the repair invoice, before and after photos, service records and an independent appraisal comparing the car's value before the crash with its value after repair. Keep copies and dates. The rule in 11 NYCRR 216.7 that an insurer requiring estimates bears their reasonable cost covers your own insurer on a collision claim, not the at-fault driver's insurer.

How much will an insurer pay for diminished value in New York?

There is no set figure. The amount depends on the car's age, mileage, condition before the crash, the kind of damage and how strong your appraisal is. The other driver's property damage limit caps what that policy pays, and the minimum under New York Vehicle and Traffic Law section 311(4)(a) is $10,000 per accident. Past results do not guarantee a similar outcome.

How long do I have to make a diminished value claim in New York?

You have three years from the crash to sue over damage to your car under New York CPLR section 214(4). A claim against a city or county vehicle needs a notice of claim within 90 days and suit within one year and 90 days. Ask early, while the repair records and the photos are fresh, and do not let adjuster talks run past your deadline.

Who can make a diminished value claim in New York?

The owner of the damaged car can, against the driver who caused the crash and that driver's property damage coverage. Being partly at fault does not end the car claim in New York, because CPLR section 1411(a) reduces the recovery by your share instead. A driver who was entirely at fault has no one to claim against.

What if the insurer refuses to pay diminished value?

Ask for the refusal and its reasons in writing. If talks stall, the claim can go to court within the three years (a city vehicle also needs a notice of claim within 90 days and suit within one year and 90 days) under CPLR section 214(4).

Reviewed by Paul Perkins, Esq.

How do you get a free case evaluation?

Fill in the four short fields in this form, and a licensed attorney reviews your case for free. We respond day or night.

  1. Tell us what happenedWhen, where and what kind of crash.
  2. An attorney reviews itAt no cost and with no obligation.
  3. We call you backTo explain your options.

Talk to an Accident Attorney

Top USA Law. Services are not available in all states.

Takes 30 seconds. No obligation.

Submitting this form does not create an attorney-client relationship. All information is kept confidential.